Jeff Turner, one of the Tiffany-obsessed fans profiled in the documentary I Think We’re Alone Now, decided he was going to drop Tiffany and start stalking Alyssa Milano instead. On the night of December 23rd, 2008 he went to the actresses’ house and things went very poorly for him. The resulting arrest and story was told on Access Hollywood and gossip blogs all over the Internet.
Here is Turner’s side of the story, as told to the I Think We’re Alone Now filmmakers: